Black tourmaline is a popular gemstone known for its protective and grounding qualities. Many people seek black tourmaline for its beauty and metaphysical properties. However, with the increasing number of fake gemstones in the market, it is crucial to know how to differentiate real black tourmaline from imitations. In this guide, we will explore various methods to help you determine if your black tourmaline is genuine or fake.
What is Black Tourmaline?
Before diving into the identification process, let’s first understand what black tourmaline is. Black tourmaline, also known as schorl, is a member of the tourmaline group of gemstones. It is well-known for its striking black color and is believed to offer protection against negative energy. Black tourmaline is commonly used in jewelry, including rings, necklaces, bracelets, and pendants.
While black tourmaline is a natural and valuable stone, there are many synthetic and imitation stones that resemble it. The main challenge for buyers is distinguishing between the authentic and fake versions.
Color of Black Tourmaline
One of the first characteristics to examine when determining the authenticity of black tourmaline is its color. Genuine black tourmaline should have a deep, rich black color. While some fake black tourmaline stones might appear jet black, they may lack the depth and natural variations found in a real piece.
Key Indicators of Fake Color
Uniformity: Fake black tourmaline may have an unnaturally uniform color across the entire gemstone. Real black tourmaline, however, has slight variations in color, especially along the edges or within the stone itself.
Lack of Sheen: Genuine black tourmaline has a vitreous (glass-like) luster and may show some reflection. If your stone looks overly matte or lacks any sheen, it might be a fake.
Deepness of Color: Real black tourmaline has a rich, deep black appearance. If the stone seems dull or has a washed-out look, it could be a synthetic or fake material.
Weight of Black Tourmaline
Real black tourmaline is relatively dense compared to many imitations. To differentiate real from fake, consider the weight of the gemstone.
Key Indicators of Fake Weight
Lightness: Fake black tourmaline made from resin or plastic is often much lighter than genuine black tourmaline. Hold the stone in your hand and compare it to other gemstones. If it feels unusually light, it is likely a fake.
Heavier Stones: While real black tourmaline is dense, some fake stones may be made with heavy but low-quality materials to mimic the feel. In such cases, you need to rely on other methods for verification.
Texture of Black Tourmaline
Black tourmaline, especially raw specimens, often has a rough texture. When polished, it can be smooth, but it retains some natural grooves or striations on the surface.
Key Indicators of Fake Texture
Smoothness: Fake stones often have a perfectly smooth texture, which may feel unnatural to the touch. Genuine black tourmaline has subtle ridges, lines, or grooves, even after polishing.
Synthetic Finish: Some fake black tourmaline pieces are made with plastic or resin and have an artificial finish. These materials may feel slippery and unnatural when compared to real black tourmaline.
Inconsistent Surface: Genuine black tourmaline may have imperfections or small surface cracks. A fake piece often has a perfect, uniform surface.
Transparency of Black Tourmaline
Tourmaline is generally opaque, but some rare specimens may show transparency in certain areas. Fake black tourmaline, made of materials like plastic or glass, may have an unnatural level of clarity or transparency.
Key Indicators of Fake Transparency
Clear or Too Transparent: If the stone shows transparency or clarity beyond what you would expect from black tourmaline, it may be fake. Black tourmaline should be opaque with very minimal, if any, transparency.
Unusual Reflections: Fake tourmaline might reflect light in an unnatural way, making it look too shiny or glass-like.
Inclusions and Bubbles
Real black tourmaline often contains natural inclusions or imperfections within the stone. These inclusions can appear as tiny air bubbles, minerals, or other features within the crystal.
Key Indicators of Fake Inclusions
No Inclusions: Fake black tourmaline made from glass, resin, or plastic often lacks inclusions. If you find a perfectly clear, flawless piece, it’s likely synthetic.
Bubbles or Artificial Inclusions: Fake black tourmaline may contain air bubbles or unnatural inclusions. Examine the stone under a magnifying glass to check for such imperfections.
Natural Striations: Real black tourmaline often has visible striations or growth patterns along the surface. These are natural characteristics of the stone’s formation process.
How to Test Black Tourmaline
Here are a few simple tests you can perform to help determine the authenticity of black tourmaline:
1. The Scratch Test
Black tourmaline is a relatively hard stone, scoring around 7-7.5 on the Mohs scale of hardness. You can perform a scratch test using a material with a lower hardness, such as a steel nail or a piece of glass. If the stone scratches easily, it is likely fake.
2. The Flame Test
This test is especially useful for identifying plastic or resin imitations. Hold the stone near a flame (but not too close) and observe its reaction. Genuine black tourmaline will not melt or change shape, whereas plastic will warp or burn. Be cautious when performing this test, as it may cause damage to the stone.
3. The Water Test
Real black tourmaline has a higher density compared to many fake materials. Drop the stone into a glass of water and see if it sinks or floats. Genuine black tourmaline will sink, while fakes made from lightweight materials may float.
4. UV Light Test
Some black tourmaline stones exhibit fluorescent properties under UV light. While not all black tourmaline shows this characteristic, if the stone glows brightly or displays unusual colors under UV light, it might not be authentic.
Cost of Black Tourmaline
Price can be a good indicator of whether a black tourmaline is real or fake. Real black tourmaline is typically more expensive due to its rarity and natural formation. Fake black tourmaline, made of plastic, resin, or glass, is usually much cheaper.
If you come across a black tourmaline being sold at a suspiciously low price, it could be an imitation. Always purchase gemstones from reputable sellers or jewelers who provide certification or guarantees of authenticity.
Certification and Professional Help
If you are still uncertain about the authenticity of your black tourmaline, consider seeking professional help. Reputable gemologists or jewelers can help verify the gemstone’s authenticity. Additionally, many genuine black tourmaline pieces come with a certificate of authenticity, confirming that the stone is natural and not synthetic.
Where to Buy Authentic Black Tourmaline
To ensure you’re buying real black tourmaline, always purchase from trusted sources. Look for reputable jewelers, online stores with good reviews, and businesses that offer certificates of authenticity. Authentic black tourmaline can often be found in well-established gemstone shops and online retailers specializing in natural gemstones.
Trusted Sources
Reputable Gemstone Stores: Look for stores with established reputations for selling genuine gemstones.
Online Jewelers: Many online jewelers specialize in selling authentic black tourmaline. Look for those with positive reviews and transparent return policies.
Certified Gemologists: Seek out jewelers and retailers who employ certified gemologists to verify the authenticity of their gemstones.
Conclusion
Knowing how to tell real black tourmaline from fake is crucial for ensuring you’re purchasing a genuine gemstone. By paying attention to factors such as color, texture, weight, transparency, and inclusions, you can identify whether your black tourmaline is real or a counterfeit. If in doubt, always consult a professional gemologist to verify your stone’s authenticity. By following these guidelines, you can confidently enjoy the beauty and metaphysical benefits of authentic black tourmaline jewelry.
Related topics:
- Can Black Tourmaline Be Worn Every Day?
- How Rare is Pink Tourmaline?
- How to Tell If Pink Tourmaline Is Real?
