Tourmaline is a boron silicate mineral occurring in a wide range of colors, and it is one of the most versatile gemstones available. Among its many varieties, black tourmaline, also known as Schorl, is the most common form. It has been prized for centuries not only for its beauty but also for its purported metaphysical properties, which include protection from negative energies and enhancement of physical vitality. Because of its popularity, it’s important to be able to identify real black tourmaline from imitations or other minerals that can look similar. This article will provide you with a comprehensive guide on how to identify genuine black tourmaline.
Understanding Black Tourmaline
What is Black Tourmaline?
Black tourmaline, or Schorl, is a type of tourmaline that is predominantly black in color. It is composed of iron, magnesium, aluminum, silicon, oxygen, and hydroxide ions. The presence of iron is what gives this variety of tourmaline its characteristic dark color. Black tourmaline is found in various locations around the world, including Brazil, Afghanistan, and the United States. Its hardness on the Mohs scale is between 7 and 7.5, making it relatively durable and suitable for jewelry use.
The Formation of Black Tourmaline
Black tourmaline forms under high pressure and temperature conditions within the Earth’s crust. It is often found in pegmatites, which are coarse-grained igneous rocks that form from the slow cooling of magma. The formation process involves the crystallization of elements like boron, silicon, and aluminum, along with trace amounts of other elements, into a structured lattice. The inclusion of iron during this process results in the deep black coloration of the stone.
Physical Properties of Black Tourmaline
Color and Transparency
One of the most distinctive features of black tourmaline is its deep, opaque black color. While some specimens may have slight variations in hue, ranging from very dark green to almost pitch-black, they should never appear translucent or transparent. If a stone labeled as black tourmaline shows any transparency, it may be a different type of gemstone or an imitation.
Crystal Habit
Black tourmaline typically forms elongated, columnar crystals that can be prismatic or needle-like. These crystals can grow quite large, and they often have striations running parallel to their length. When looking at a piece of black tourmaline, you might notice these natural lines or grooves on the surface, which can help confirm its authenticity.
Luster
When polished, black tourmaline exhibits a vitreous (glassy) to sub-metallic luster. This means that the surface of the stone can reflect light in a way that is both bright and shiny, yet not as reflective as a metal. A dull or matte finish could indicate that the stone has been treated or is not true black tourmaline.
Hardness and Durability
As mentioned earlier, black tourmaline has a hardness of 7 to 7.5 on the Mohs scale. This makes it relatively hard and resistant to scratches, which is beneficial for jewelry applications. However, it is still less durable than diamonds or sapphires, so care should be taken when wearing pieces made from this material. If the stone appears to be easily scratched or damaged, it may not be authentic black tourmaline.
Testing Methods for Authenticity
Visual Inspection
A visual inspection is the first step in identifying real black tourmaline. Look for the characteristics described above, such as color, crystal habit, and luster. Pay attention to the shape and structure of the stone, as well as any inclusions or imperfections that might be present. Natural stones often have small flaws or inclusions, which can be a sign of authenticity. Imitations or synthetic stones, on the other hand, tend to be too perfect and lack the natural variations found in genuine gems.
Magnification
Using a jeweler’s loupe or microscope can reveal details that are not visible to the naked eye. Under magnification, you may be able to see internal structures, such as growth lines or fractures, which are indicative of natural formation. Additionally, magnification can help you spot any signs of treatment or alteration, such as filled cracks or coatings that have been applied to enhance the appearance of the stone.
Specific Gravity Test
The specific gravity of a gemstone is a measure of its density relative to water. Black tourmaline has a specific gravity that ranges from 3.06 to 3.29. To perform this test, you would need specialized equipment, such as a hydrostatic balance. By measuring the weight of the stone in air and then in water, you can calculate its specific gravity and compare it to the expected value for black tourmaline. If the result falls outside this range, the stone may not be authentic.
Refractive Index Measurement
The refractive index (RI) is a measure of how much light is bent when it passes through a material. For black tourmaline, the RI typically falls between 1.624 and 1.644. Using a refractometer, a professional gemologist can measure the RI of a stone and determine whether it matches that of black tourmaline. This test requires a certain level of expertise and the right tools, so it is usually performed by a certified appraiser or laboratory.
Thermal Conductivity Testing
Some gem testing devices, like thermal conductivity testers, can distinguish between different types of materials based on how well they conduct heat. Black tourmaline has a relatively low thermal conductivity, meaning it does not conduct heat as efficiently as metals or some other gemstones. This property can be used to differentiate it from imitations that may have a higher thermal conductivity, such as glass or plastic.
Electrical Conductivity Testing
Interestingly, black tourmaline is piezoelectric, which means it can generate an electrical charge when subjected to mechanical stress. This unique property can be tested using a specialized instrument called a pyroelectric or piezoelectric tester. When the stone is heated or cooled, or when pressure is applied, it should produce a detectable electrical charge. If the stone does not exhibit this behavior, it may not be real black tourmaline.
Common Imitations and Misidentifications
Glass Imitations
Glass can sometimes be used to imitate black tourmaline due to its similar appearance and cost-effectiveness. However, there are several ways to tell the difference. Glass imitations tend to have a more uniform color and lack the natural inclusions and striations found in genuine black tourmaline. They also have a lower hardness on the Mohs scale, making them more susceptible to scratches. Furthermore, glass does not possess the same thermal or electrical properties as black tourmaline, so tests related to these characteristics can help identify imitations.
Dyed Stones
Some stones, such as quartz or onyx, can be dyed to resemble black tourmaline. Dyeing can alter the color of a stone, but it cannot change its underlying properties. Dyed stones may show uneven color distribution, especially around the edges or in areas where the dye has concentrated. Under magnification, you might also notice that the dye has pooled in certain spots or created a web-like pattern. Chemical tests can be used to detect the presence of dyes, but these should be conducted by a professional to avoid damaging the stone.
Synthetic Tourmaline
Synthetic versions of black tourmaline can be produced in laboratories, but they are relatively rare compared to natural stones. Synthetic tourmaline is grown using techniques that mimic the natural formation process, resulting in a material that closely resembles the real thing. However, there are subtle differences that can be detected by experts. For example, synthetic stones may have a more consistent color and fewer inclusions than their natural counterparts. They can also have a slightly different chemical composition or crystal structure, which can be revealed through advanced testing methods.
Other Minerals
Several other minerals can be mistaken for black tourmaline due to their similar appearance. These include:
- Hornblende: A silicate mineral that can have a dark green to black color. It has a lower hardness than black tourmaline and lacks the piezoelectric property.
- Biotite Mica: A mica group mineral that can appear black and has a flaky, layered structure. It is softer than black tourmaline and can be distinguished by its cleavage and flexibility.
- Obsidian: A volcanic glass that can be jet black in color. It has a conchoidal fracture, meaning it breaks into curved fragments, and it is much softer than black tourmaline.
Professional Appraisal and Certification
If you are unsure about the authenticity of a black tourmaline piece, it is always a good idea to seek the opinion of a professional gemologist. A certified appraiser can perform a thorough examination using a combination of the testing methods discussed above. They can also provide a detailed report that includes information about the stone’s origin, quality, and value. Many reputable organizations, such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), offer certification services for gemstones, which can give you added assurance about your purchase.
Conclusion
Identifying real black tourmaline requires a combination of knowledge, experience, and the right tools. By familiarizing yourself with the physical properties of this gemstone and learning how to perform basic tests, you can become more confident in your ability to distinguish it from imitations or other minerals. However, for the most accurate and reliable results, it is recommended to consult with a professional gemologist or obtain a certification from a recognized institution. Whether you are a collector, a jewelry enthusiast, or simply someone who appreciates the beauty of nature, knowing how to identify real black tourmaline can enhance your appreciation and enjoyment of this remarkable gemstone.
- What Are Natural Green Tourmaline Loose Stones?
- Tsavorite Vs Tourmaline: What Is the Difference?
- How to Identify Blue and Pink Tourmaline?